13 Best TMS Software in 2024

Selecting the right Transportation Management System (TMS) is crucial for businesses looking to streamline their logistics operations, improve efficiency, and cut costs. With so many options available, it can be challenging to choose the best TMS for your needs. We’ve curated a list of 13 top TMS solutions for 2024, providing insights into their features, limitations, and what makes them stand out. Whether you’re a small business or a large enterprise, this will help you find the right software to enhance your supply chain management.

Criteria for Choosing the Best TMS Software

When selecting the best Transportation Management System (TMS) for your business, it’s essential to consider several key factors. These criteria help ensure that the software aligns with your logistics goals, enhances efficiency, and provides value to your operations.

Cost and Pricing Structure: One of the first things to consider is the pricing model. Some TMS solutions may have high upfront costs but offer extensive features, while others offer subscription-based plans. It’s crucial to choose a solution that fits within your budget while providing the necessary tools for growth.

Integration Capabilities: A good TMS should seamlessly integrate with existing systems such as your ERP, WMS, or CRM. This ensures smooth data flow and reduces the risk of operational disruptions during implementation.

Ease of Use: The software should have an intuitive interface that allows your team to quickly adapt and operate without extensive training. A user-friendly design saves time and reduces the potential for human error in complex logistics processes.

Customization and Scalability: Every business has unique needs, so flexibility in customization is vital. Additionally, the software should be scalable to accommodate future growth or changes in your supply chain.

Real-Time Visibility and Reporting: For effective decision-making, a TMS should provide real-time shipment tracking and comprehensive reporting capabilities. This helps you stay updated on your logistics operations and allows for proactive management of potential issues.

Customer Support and Training: A strong support system is crucial for troubleshooting and ensuring a smooth user experience. Look for a TMS provider that offers excellent customer service, including responsive support teams and accessible training resources.

By evaluating these factors, you can confidently select a TMS solution that enhances your supply chain management, boosts efficiency, and supports business growth.

Top TMS Software in 2024

TMS Software	Best For	Pros	Cons
GoComet	Automating and optimizing freight procurement for any business size	– User-friendly – Real-time tracking – Collaboration tools	– No offline functionality
3Gtms	Businesses with complex transportation networks requiring dynamic routing	– Improves supply chain visibility and control. – Automates processes like load planning and route optimization. – Offers real-time tracking and collaboration.	– Requires customization for multi-system integration. – Implementation can be time-consuming.
e2open	Improving supply chain visibility and collaboration across multiple partners	– Real-time visibility – Freight optimization – Stakeholder collaboration	– Limited integration with non-e2open systems – No free trial
Descartes	Flexible and scalable solutions for businesses of all sizes	– Automated freight tendering – Load planning – Real-time shipment visibility	– Advanced reporting only in premium plans – Steep learning curve
Blue Yonder	Enterprises seeking predictive analytics for logistics optimization	– Route optimization – Predictive analytics – Carrier management	– Requires IT support – Expensive customization
Manhattan	Large enterprises needing end-to-end visibility and control over operations	– Order consolidation – Real-time tracking – Mode optimization	– Limited appeal for small businesses – Steep learning curve
MercuryGate	Enterprises looking for scalable TMS solutions with advanced analytics	– Multi-modal support – Automated carrier selection – Real-time monitoring	– Extensive training required – Limited global scalability
Oracle	Businesses seeking integration with other Oracle products	– Seamless integration – Route optimization – Collaboration tools	– Expensive for small businesses – Dependency on Oracle ecosystem
Project44	Businesses focused on enhancing supply chain visibility and real-time tracking	– Real-time tracking – Predictive analytics – Carrier connectivity	– No port congestion status data – Limited offline capabilities
SAP	Enterprises needing comprehensive logistics solutions integrated with SAP products	– Freight planning – Carrier collaboration – Transportation analytics	– Expensive for small enterprises – Requires SAP system integration
TMC – A Division of C.H. Robinson	Businesses looking for vast carrier network and logistics capabilities	– Extensive carrier network – Freight optimization – Live Shipment tracking	– Requires logistics expertise – Limited scalability for global operations
Trimble	Businesses seeking streamlined transportation operations	– Route optimization – Load planning – Real-time tracking	– Lacks advanced analytics
Uber Freight TMS	Businesses looking for modern TMS with load matching and real-time tracking	– Freight procurement – Load matching – Predictive analytics	– Limited customization – Primarily for mid-to-large enterprises

The Top 13 TMS Software Solutions for 2024

1. GoComet

GoComet is a leading choice for businesses that prioritize simplicity and efficiency in freight management. Its cloud-based platform caters to a wide range of industries, helping users optimize their logistics operations with minimal manual intervention. GoComet’s real-time tracking ensures users always know where their shipments are, making it an invaluable tool for maintaining supply chain visibility.

The platform also excels in fostering collaboration between carriers and shippers. By automating tedious tasks, GoComet allows logistics teams to focus on strategic planning rather than administrative details. It’s particularly well-suited for companies looking to save costs and enhance productivity without a steep learning curve.

Key Features:

• Automated Freight Procurement: Streamlines freight rate and contract management, reducing manual effort and minimizing errors.
• Real-Time Shipment Tracking: Provides continuous updates on shipment locations, improving visibility and reducing uncertainty throughout the supply chain.
• Performance Analytics: Delivers actionable insights into carrier efficiency and freight costs, enabling better decision-making and cost optimization.
• Collaboration Tools: Facilitates seamless communication across carriers, suppliers, and internal teams, ensuring alignment and faster issue resolution.

Limitations: 

• Road Tracking Gaps: The road tracking functionality could be improved to match the robustness seen in other modes of transport, offering users more detailed visibility for road shipments.

Ratings:

Testimonials: 

“The best part about the Gocomet software is that all the interaction with the vendors via email, phone, etc. are completely eliminated. The communication is all done via software. The prime feature is the visibility of all the quotation and the cost heads are compared from each quotations from all the vendors.”

2. 3Gtms

3Gtms is designed for businesses with complex logistics needs, making it a favorite among large-scale operations. It offers unmatched flexibility in route planning, ensuring that even the most intricate transportation networks can be optimized for better performance. The software’s ability to adapt to various shipping modes sets it apart in a competitive market.

What makes 3Gtms stand out is its focus on empowering users to take control of their logistics strategies. From managing last-minute changes to integrating seamlessly with existing systems, the platform is built to handle demanding supply chain environments. It’s a great fit for companies that deal with diverse transportation challenges regularly.

Key Features:

• Real-Time Dynamic Routing: Continuously adjusts transportation routes based on live data to improve efficiency and reduce delays.
• Multi-Modal Transportation: Supports a variety of transportation methods (e.g., road, rail, air, and sea), providing seamless management across different modes.
• Freight Optimization: Minimizes empty miles and maximizes load efficiency to lower shipping costs while improving environmental impact.
• Carrier Collaboration: Enhances communication and coordination with carriers to ensure smoother, more efficient logistics operations.

Limitations: 

3. e2open

e2open stands out for its deep focus on improving supply chain collaboration. By integrating transportation management with other supply chain functions, the software helps users maintain a seamless flow of information across teams. This interconnected approach makes it easier to align logistics strategies with overall business goals.

The platform also supports businesses looking to streamline operations and reduce inefficiencies. Its data-driven insights enable smarter decision-making, ensuring that resources are allocated effectively. e2open’s emphasis on visibility and transparency makes it a top choice for companies that rely heavily on supply chain data.

Key Features:

• Predictive ETAs: Leverages advanced analytics to provide more accurate and reliable estimated times of arrival (ETAs) for shipments.
• Carrier Invoice Comparison & Cost Reduction: Simplifies the invoice comparison process, helping businesses identify discrepancies, negotiate better contracts, and ultimately reduce logistics costs.
• Real-Time Shipment Visibility: Offers end-to-end visibility of shipments across all transportation modes, enabling real-time tracking and improving decision-making.
• Centralized Shipment Bookings: Allows users to manage and streamline all shipment bookings in a single platform, simplifying the booking process.

Limitations: 

4. Descartes

Descartes is ideal for businesses seeking scalability and flexibility in their transportation management processes. Its user-centric design allows teams to manage large-scale operations without being overwhelmed. The software’s compliance features make it particularly appealing to industries with strict regulatory requirements.

Another strength of Descartes is its ability to adapt to changing logistics needs. Whether you’re handling international shipments or managing a domestic fleet, the platform offers the tools needed to stay efficient. Its emphasis on detailed reporting also makes it easier to identify areas for continuous improvement.

Key Features:

• Carrier Management: Centralize carrier details, rates, and performance data in one place, making it easier to choose the best carriers and negotiate better rates based on historical performance.
• Lane Rate Consolidation: Consolidates all lane rates and related data into a single, accessible view. This makes it easier to analyze and compare different shipping lanes, improving decision-making for logistics.
• Load Matching: Use historical and real-time data to match loads with the most suitable carriers. This helps ensure optimal routing and cost efficiency by leveraging past performance and current conditions.
• Invoicing and Reporting Tools: Streamline invoicing and generate reports effortlessly. These tools simplify financial tracking and reporting, saving time and reducing errors in billing processes.

Limitations:

5. Blue Yonder

Blue Yonder is tailored for businesses that value predictive analytics in their logistics operations. It uses advanced algorithms to provide actionable recommendations, helping users stay ahead of potential disruptions. This forward-thinking approach makes it a reliable partner for optimizing transportation processes.

The software’s intuitive interface and seamless integration capabilities further enhance its appeal. Blue Yonder is particularly effective for enterprises looking to unify their logistics operations under one platform. It’s a great option for companies ready to invest in smarter, data-driven transportation solutions.

Key Features:

• Route Optimization: Uses advanced algorithms to plan the most efficient delivery routes, reducing travel time and costs while improving on-time delivery performance.
• Predictive Analytics: Analyzes historical data and current trends to predict potential supply chain disruptions, allowing businesses to proactively adjust and minimize impact.
• Carrier Management Tools: Streamlines the process of managing transportation providers, from selection to performance monitoring, ensuring smoother collaboration and optimized shipping.
• Freight Auditing: Automatically checks freight invoices for accuracy, identifying discrepancies and overcharges to ensure businesses only pay for the services they’ve received.

Limitations: 

• Slow System Response and Integration Issues: Users report delays in system performance, particularly with the FOM/TMS bridge and EDI setups, requiring additional resources and time to resolve integration problems.
• Outdated User Interface and Limited Customization: The platform’s user interface is often described as clunky and difficult to navigate, while customization options for certain features, such as sourcing and procurement, are limited.

Ratings:

Testimonials: 

“It is easy to integrate with the Blue Yonder WMS module, however, for other systems you will need to develop integration.”

6. Manhattan

Manhattan excels at providing complete control over logistics operations for large enterprises. Its powerful tools make managing complex supply chains straightforward and efficient. The platform is built to handle high volumes, ensuring reliability even during peak operations.

Beyond efficiency, Manhattan focuses on providing businesses with deeper visibility into their logistics. The platform helps users identify bottlenecks and optimize workflows, saving time and reducing costs. It’s an excellent choice for companies seeking scalable solutions that can grow alongside their business needs.

Key Features:

• Continuous Optimization: Provides dynamic, scalable optimization based on real-time data, like weather and traffic.
• Smart Planning and Visualization: Offers interactive maps and real-time updates for efficient route and load management.
• Scenario Testing and Bid Optimization: Allows testing of multiple planning scenarios and optimizes carrier bidding with historical and forecast data.
• Fleet and Resource Management: Efficiently manages fleet resources, balances loads, and supports compliance with driver-focused tools.

Limitations: 

• Limited Customization for Small Shippers: Difficult configuration for small shippers, with slow optimization run times as the business grows.
• Integration and Connectivity Issues: Problems with delivery mapping, dynamic routing, and incomplete courier integrations disrupt efficiency.

Ratings:

Testimonials: 

“While the system is now operating and we continue to utilize additional functionality the process to implement the system left us wondering if we would ever see value from the system.”

7. MercuryGate

MercuryGate is a strong contender for businesses that need a versatile TMS platform. Its support for multi-modal transportation makes it suitable for companies managing diverse logistics operations. The software is also known for its advanced analytics, which helps users make informed decisions.

In addition to its technical capabilities, MercuryGate emphasizes user experience. Its intuitive interface and comprehensive support make it easy to onboard new team members quickly. For businesses aiming to improve efficiency without overhauling their existing processes, MercuryGate is an excellent choice.

Key Features:

• Claims Management: This feature enables businesses to initiate, manage, and report on freight claims, aiming to recover lost revenue due to damaged or delayed goods.
• Final Mile: MercuryGate provides vehicle routing and scheduling solutions that cover the entire journey, from the first mile to the last mile, ensuring efficiency in final-mile delivery.
• Product Integrity & Compliance: The platform centralizes and digitizes product compliance tracking, helping businesses minimize risks and costs associated with regulatory compliance.
• Shipment & Order Visibility: Users can track merchandise at the container, SKU, and item levels, across different transport modes including ocean, road, or rail. This provides end-to-end visibility of shipments.

Limitations: 

• Complex Customization and Legacy UI: The extensive customization options can become confusing and hard to manage over time, while the legacy UI is difficult to learn and not user-friendly.
• Integration Issues: The lack of open API and poor integration with ERP and WMS systems limits automation and compatibility with other applications, especially for international and intermodal shipping.

Ratings:

Testimonials: 

“As a legacy TMS, MercuryGate has a good reputation for flexibility in use as well as a strong logistics understanding. The glaring weakness is in their lack of a modern API, making integrations and automations very difficult to setup.”

8. Oracle

Oracle TMS is built for businesses that require seamless integration across their supply chain systems. It offers a unified platform where users can manage freight, plan routes, and collaborate with stakeholders effectively. Oracle’s reputation for reliability ensures that the software delivers consistent performance.

One of Oracle’s key strengths is its ability to handle large volumes of data without compromising speed or accuracy. This makes it ideal for enterprises looking to scale operations while maintaining tight control over logistics. The platform’s extensive customization options also ensure it can meet a variety of business needs.

Key Features:

• Optimized Planning: Enhances transportation efficiency by using historical data for route and shipping plan optimization.
• Automation: Streamlines tasks like billing and performance tracking, reducing manual effort and increasing accuracy.
• Fleet Management: Helps manage and optimize internal and external fleet operations for smoother logistics.
• AI Integration: Uses machine learning for better predictions of transit times and resource allocation, improving decision-making.

Limitations: 

• Expensive for Small Businesses: The subscription fees are high, making it a less viable option for businesses with limited budgets.
• Dependency on Oracle Ecosystem: For optimal use, businesses need to be fully integrated into the Oracle product suite, which might not suit all companies.

Ratings:

Testimonials: 

“The best part is Security and the performance. As usual…every product needs enhancements…so this product for sure need some additional functionalities which would help different types of businesses.“

9. Project44

Project44 is the go-to solution for businesses focused on enhancing visibility in their logistics operations. Its real-time tracking features allow users to monitor shipments closely, reducing uncertainties and improving customer satisfaction. The platform is particularly valuable for companies with high expectations for on-time delivery.

What sets Project44 apart is its emphasis on collaboration. By connecting carriers and shippers, the software fosters better communication and reduces misunderstandings. It’s a reliable option for companies aiming to build stronger partnerships within their supply chain.

Key Features:

• End-to-End Logistics Management: Manage ocean, air, rail, and road shipments globally from a single platform.
• Delivery Optimization: Use machine learning insights to improve delivery times and make better decisions.
• Port Congestion Alerts: Access real-time port data to avoid delays caused by congestion.
• Procurement Automation: Streamline procurement with automated ratings, bookings, and document handling.

Limitations: 

Ratings:

Testimonials: 

“Last year, our review stated that we would like to have more fuzzy data accpeted, and that is now possible. There are constant improvements with the product. Our support rep is always helpful. Easier tracking for non-US carriers. Currently, if a carrier is not registered with the FMCSA we cannot track.“

10. SAP

SAP TMS leverages its ecosystem to deliver a highly integrated logistics solution. The platform is designed to work seamlessly with other SAP products, making it an attractive option for businesses already invested in SAP software. It simplifies logistics processes, ensuring smooth workflows across teams.

The software also excels in delivering detailed analytics, giving users a clear picture of their logistics performance. From tracking shipments to optimizing carrier contracts, SAP TMS helps businesses maximize their logistics efficiency. Its focus on scalability ensures it remains relevant as businesses grow.

Key Features:

• Strategic Freight Management: Automates quote-to-contract processes and rate determination for optimized freight management.
• Transportation Planning: Enhances goods movement and delivery management with clear visibility and improved efficiency.
• Interactive Freight Tendering: Enables real-time, dynamic freight bidding for cost-effective and sustainable shipping.
• Generative AI Innovations: Leverages AI to streamline decision-making, reduce risks, and improve delivery performance.

Limitations: 

“SAP has a broad set of solutions as an ERP Vendor, but the benefits of their scale are also a drawback when it comes to agility and service.“

11. TMC – A Division of C.H. Robinson

TMC specializes in leveraging its parent company’s vast carrier network to provide unmatched logistics capabilities. Its platform enables businesses to access a wide range of transportation options, ensuring flexibility and cost savings. The software’s real-time data features are crucial for maintaining supply chain visibility.

In addition to operational efficiency, TMC focuses on empowering users with actionable insights. Its robust analytics tools help businesses optimize routes, reduce waste, and improve overall logistics performance. It’s a trusted choice for companies with demanding transportation needs.

Key Features:

• Freightquote for Small Businesses: Instant shipment quotes, carrier selection, and scheduling, with rewards for higher shipping volumes.
• Custom Solutions for Larger Companies: Tailored freight quotes and services based on shipment needs and market insights for mid to enterprise-sized businesses.
• Industry-Specific Expertise: Customized solutions for various sectors like automotive, healthcare, and retail, backed by deep industry knowledge.
• Advanced Supply Chain Visibility: Tools for disruption mitigation, enhanced maps, and custom notifications to proactively manage supply chain issues.

Limitations: 

Ratings:

Testimonials: 

“The company has always been helpful in solving problems and responding quickly. There is no other complaint really but the website can be kind of difficult at times to figure out what exactly you need to go to find something.“

12. Trimble

Trimble is a reliable choice for businesses aiming to streamline transportation operations. Its platform simplifies complex logistics workflows, making it easy to plan routes, manage loads, and monitor shipments. The software is especially popular among mid-sized businesses looking for practical solutions.

Trimble also emphasizes collaboration, offering tools that keep all supply chain stakeholders on the same page. This improves communication and reduces delays, helping businesses maintain efficiency. It’s a strong option for companies looking to improve both visibility and operational control.

Key Features:

• Cloud-Based Freight Management: Trimble’s transportation solutions offer cloud-based platforms like Transporeon, which enable shippers, carriers, and brokers to seamlessly move, manage, and track freight across the supply chain.
• Advanced Routing and Optimization: Trimble’s technology uses sophisticated algorithms to optimize routes, manage fuel costs, and ensure efficient load matching, improving both trip performance and cost-efficiency.
• Maintenance and Asset Management: Trimble’s maintenance software helps maximize the efficiency and uptime of transport trucks, ensuring fleet reliability and minimizing downtime, which ultimately boosts profitability.
• Safety and Compliance Assurance: Trimble’s solutions are designed to enhance driver safety and fleet compliance with federal transportation regulations, helping businesses avoid penalties while maintaining operational safety standards.

Limitations: 

• Outdated User Interface: Several users have mentioned that Trimble TMS has an old, clunky design that feels outdated and inefficient, especially with the reliance on outdated technologies like Silverlight. This makes the software harder to navigate and less user-friendly.
• Limited Customization and Analysis Features: Users have noted that Trimble TMS lacks advanced analysis tools and customizable reports, limiting its ability to provide detailed, tailored insights. Additionally, customization for certain functions can be time-consuming and complex.

Ratings:

Testimonials: 

“I like that I’m able to use it for several different subgroups, like operations and accounting. It is one way to keep all the information consistent. It’s almost just too much information, we are still learning about how to use the reports so we can decipher the information we want.“

13. Uber Freight TMS (formerly Transplace)

Uber Freight TMS combines modern technology with a user-friendly interface to simplify freight management. Its load-matching capabilities make it easier for businesses to connect with the right carriers, saving time and costs. The platform also supports real-time communication, keeping operations running smoothly.

What makes Uber Freight TMS unique is its ability to scale with businesses. Whether you’re managing a small fleet or overseeing a global supply chain, the platform provides the flexibility needed to adapt. It’s an ideal choice for companies that value innovation in logistics.

Key Features:

• AI-Optimized Network: Provides real-time data to optimize operations and improve visibility across the logistics network.
• Dynamic Capacity Solutions: Offers flexible capacity management across various transportation modes to meet fluctuating business needs.
• End-to-End Logistics Solutions: Delivers a full range of services, from software tools to expert consulting, to optimize the supply chain.
• Sustainability Focus: Introduces eco-friendly initiatives like autonomous truck deployment to reduce the environmental impact of freight transportation.

Limitations: 

• Limited Customization: The platform lacks flexibility to tailor solutions for specific business needs, such as differentiated services and key account management.
• Delayed Reporting and Data Accuracy: Users face 24+ hour delays in reporting and issues with inaccurate load updates, affecting decision-making and efficiency.

Ratings:

Testimonials: 

“The tool works; however, the user interface is not ‘simple’. Too many fields need to be entered to pull data. Reports are not customizable.”

Conclusion

Choosing the right Transportation Management System (TMS) can significantly improve your logistics operations, enhancing efficiency, reducing costs, and boosting supply chain visibility. By evaluating the features, limitations, and unique strengths of each software, businesses can make an informed decision that aligns with their specific needs. Whether you’re focused on automation, real-time tracking, or seamless integration, there’s a TMS solution on this list that can help optimize your operations. Take the time to assess your logistics challenges and select a TMS that will drive success for your business in 2024 and beyond.